Palm-lined downtown shopping street at dusk, with illuminated storefronts and cars.

Port Royal vs. Aqualane Shores vs. Old Naples

Call Justin: 239-273-0365

Updated October 2026

By Justin Falta, Broker Associate with Premier Sotheby's International Realty

Port Royal, Aqualane Shores and Old Naples sit side by side in ZIP 34102, at the south end of the Naples peninsula. They share the Gulf of America beaches, Fifth Avenue South, Third Street South and boating access through Gordon Pass, but they deliver very different daily lives at very different prices. The costly mistake is touring all three as if they were interchangeable.

The Short Version

Port Royal

Aqualane Shores

Old Naples

Character

Private estate enclave

Canal-front boating neighborhood

Walkable historic town center

Typical home

Large waterfront estates, many on wide water or the Gulf

Canal-front homes, many with private docks

Cottages, custom homes and condominiums

Boating

Deepwater dockage for larger vessels

Close-in daily boating, generally without fixed bridges to Gordon Pass

Beach first, boat second

Walkability

Short drive to Third Street and Fifth Avenue

Walk or bike to Third Street and the beach

Most walkable luxury address in Naples

Club

Port Royal Club, tied to property ownership

None required

None required

Port Royal: The Estate and the Address

Port Royal is the flagship waterfront neighborhood of Naples, made up almost entirely of single-family estates. Most homes sit on Naples Bay, wide canals or the Gulf, and the most coveted streets include Gordon Drive, Rum Row, Gin Lane, Galleon Drive, Fort Charles Drive and Admiralty Parade. The house is the amenity: wide waterways, outdoor living on a large scale and docks built for serious yachts.

Membership in the private Port Royal Club is tied to property ownership in the neighborhood, and the club is completing a new Gulf-front clubhouse. Port Royal is the most expensive of the three, and it has produced the highest residential sale in Florida history: $225 million for three adjoining Gordon Drive properties in April 2025. Read our full Port Royal neighborhood guide.

Choose Port Royal if you want maximum privacy, estate scale, deepwater dockage for a larger vessel and a beach club tied to your address.

Aqualane Shores: Dock the Boat, Walk to Dinner

Aqualane Shores sits between Port Royal and Old Naples, and that position is its appeal. It began in 1949, when Forrest Walker and his sons dredged canals and filled lots out of mangrove land, and it was planned around waterfront homesites. Its canals connect to Naples Bay and out through Gordon Pass, generally without fixed bridges, which allows larger boats than many Naples canal neighborhoods.

Lots are smaller than in Port Royal, so new construction often builds up. Housing ranges from renovated mid-century homes to new custom estates. There is a voluntary neighborhood association rather than a gated, mandatory club structure.

Choose Aqualane Shores if you want a private dock as a daily habit and still want to walk or bike to Third Street South and the beach.

Read the Aqualane Shores neighborhood guide for current homes in the neighborhood.

Old Naples: The Walkable Waterfront

Old Naples is the city's original core: tree-lined blocks between the Gulf and U.S. 41, with Fifth Avenue South, Third Street South, the Naples Pier and Cambier Park within a few blocks. Many east-west avenues end at the beach. Housing runs from early cottages to new three-story custom homes and condominiums, so the price range is the widest of the three. See our Old Naples neighborhood page for current homes.

Choose Old Naples if your daily life is restaurants, galleries, the pier and a short walk to the Gulf.

What Your Budget Points To

  • Lower budgets for the area generally start in Old Naples, where condominiums and smaller homes widen the range. Prime waterfront in Port Royal and Aqualane Shores sits well above this level.
  • In the middle, buyers usually choose between an Aqualane Shores canal home and a strong Old Naples custom home near the beach or Fifth Avenue. In Port Royal, the same budget often points to an older waterfront home bought largely for its lot.
  • At the top, finished new Aqualane waterfront, premier Old Naples beach-block homes and true Port Royal wide-water estates all come into play. Gulf-front Port Royal sits above all of it.

Because inventory in all three neighborhoods is thin, current prices move quickly. Browse current Naples listings or ask us for a private comparison.

What to Check on Any Waterfront Home Here

  • Water depth, bridge clearances and run time to the Gulf for your specific boat
  • A home's elevation, construction era and insurance costs, especially on older homes
  • Dock, seawall and lift condition
  • Whether the land, not the house, is carrying the price

Which 34102 Address Fits You?

Port Royal, Aqualane Shores and Old Naples sit side by side, but they are not interchangeable. I'll help you match boat, walkability and budget before you tour.

Start a private conversation

Frequently Asked Questions

Which of the three neighborhoods is the most expensive?

Port Royal, by price, lot size and recognition. Aqualane Shores sits in the middle, and Old Naples has the widest range because it includes condominiums and cottages as well as major custom homes.

Which is best for boaters?

Aqualane Shores for close-in daily boating, and Port Royal for larger estate dockage in a more private setting. Always check the specific canal.

Can you walk to Fifth Avenue South from Port Royal?

It is a short drive or bike ride rather than a walk for most of the neighborhood. Aqualane Shores and Old Naples are more walkable.

What ZIP code are they in?

All three are primarily in Naples, FL 34102.

Related reading

Considering a sale in Port Royal, Aqualane Shores or Old Naples?Request a confidential valuation.

Searching in Port Royal, Aqualane Shores or Old Naples?Request private alerts for new and off-market Port Royal, Aqualane Shores or Old Naples listings.

Considering a purchase in Naples?Read the Naples luxury buyer's guide.

Justin Falta, Broker Associate, Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 239-273-0365 | [email protected]

Work With Justin

No matter where you are in your real estate journey, I’m here to help you achieve your goals with confidence. Browse my site for the latest real estate insights, and reach out anytime, Contact Justin today!

Follow Me on Instagram